Blog Partner Discussion 6: Biography
http://jamaicablogpartners.blogspot.com/
Your personal response to the book
What genre you think it might be and why
( Read Check out descriptions of genres at:
http://www.edu.uleth.ca/currlab/handouts/genres.html
Evaluate its literary quality
Evaluate its illustrations
Evaluate in terms of multicultural considerations including the credibility of the author and illustrator
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Title: Rapunzel
ReplyDeleteAuthor/illustrator: Paul O. Zelisky
Rapunzel" retold and illustrated Paul O. Zelisky is a version of the fairytale more closely relating to its original form dating back to 1635 called "Petrosinella". The story of "Rapunzel" has been found all over the world and has transcended time and culture, with few minor changes in the detail of the story for instance Rapunzel's hair color. The most distinctive difference between Zelisky's version and more modern interpretations, beginning with the Brother's Grimm is whether or not Rapunzel's pregnancy is mentioned. I think the story is for a more mature audience but children are not likely to catch the fact that Rapunzel is pregnant because they will be enchanted with the illustrations. The illustrations are reminiscent of the Italian Renaissance and will transport any reader into the fantasy world. Having researched several versions of Rapunzel, I have found that Zelisky's version is the most real to life because it does raise issues of sex, the inability for some parents to take care of their children, stealing, and cruelty to others. This book is provocative and will make readers of all ages asked questions; I would recommend this book for both children and adults. I think that both age groups could learn from each other by reading this book together, just be ready to answer your child's questions honestly.
This book can be classified as a traditional literature book nicola, do you agree?
ReplyDeleteThe language builds voabulary even though it is very simple.Personally, I think the novel naturally evokes interest and the plot is so interesting that you cant wait to reach the end to find out what the outcome is going to be.The setting created by the auhor conjures of images of what living in that era would be like. This novel can be used to teach listening skills sequencing, and descriptive writing, and is suitable for grade3 and 4. What do think Nicola?
ReplyDeleteHow could i forget.Nicola, did you realize that the book got a Caldcotte award? This speaks volume to the content and the overall presentation of the book.
ReplyDeleteHey nicola, I was thinking that this book can also be used to teach critical thikning skills. what do you think about that?
ReplyDeleteTitle: Rapunzel
ReplyDeleteAuthor/illustrator: Paul O. Zelisky
This book broyght back so much memory. I remeber reading this book as a child and I was captivated by it. Just looking at the pictures or illustrations are so clear, one just need to just take a look and then being taken away with imagination.
I am a mother two and I do share an honest relationship. This book can be used to teach any grade necessary, but I think that it can be ideal for grades four to six. It can be used as a Readers Theatre activity. Students in Jamaica will have a problem relating to this book because of the setting. This book can also be used at home as a lesson to both parents and children. I agree with you Candice that this book is a Traditional Literature and yeas I also discovered that this book won a Caldicott award because of its literary quality.
ReplyDeleteSo Candice what do you think the vobcabulary of this book was like? I think the vocabulary of this book is mamagable for students who read frequently. This book allow individuals to think critically and rationally. To tell you the truth Candice, everything about this book is good and i would recommend it to any curious reader.
ReplyDelete